Why Today’s Customers Expect Insurance to Work Like Amazon

AIInsurance
Oct 12, 2026
9 Min Read
Why Today’s Customers Expect Insurance to Work Like Amazon

Why Do Customers Expect Amazon-Like Experiences from Insurance Providers?

Customers expect instant gratification. Why can’t our policy holders quote, pay, track, and claim our services in the shortest time possible? With competitors aligned towards excellent customer experience and service, insurance companies should revamp their systems, processes and policy to match the needs of the client, increasing speed and reducing customer effort.

The Rise of the Digital-First Customer

Customers of insurance products are increasingly similar to customers of products and services in other markets, especially in their expectations regarding digital tools, processes and experience.

A recent survey found that over 47% of customers in 2026 purchased their auto or home insurance policies through a digital channel.

There are specific expectations of insurers by customers that are similar to expectations of other financial services. Customers expect the insurer will:

  • Provide quotes in a timely manner
  • Enable comparison of alternative insurance products and coverage
  • Allow customers to purchase and amend coverage online
  • Give customers the ability to upload and/or electronically submit documents
  • Provide an online process to report and/or submit a claim
  • Offer online process to amend coverage and/or claim status

A digital first insurance company integrates its processes and systems to provide a connected insurance journey.

A digital first, connected and customer centered insurance journey reduces the number of points in the insurance process where customers are required to engage with the insurance company in person or over the phone.

Instant Access, Real-Time Updates, and the New Service Standard

Customers are accustomed to instant and real time access to information and have rightfully high expectations for service providers to facilitate the same. This is especially true during the claims process.

  1. Claims Process Transparency
    Customers do not want to repeatedly call to find out the status of their claim.
  2. Digital Case Management
    Claims management systems should digitally represent the claims process and contain case management functionalities.
  3. Automated Updates
    Rather than requiring the customer to initiate a request for information, the claim system should automatically notify the customer of the status and next steps in the process.
  4. Dynamic Case Information
    Customers should have the ability to access claims and policy information 24/7.
  5. 5.Reduced Ambigue, Increased Certainty
    J.D. Power 2025 study reported that only 22% of digital updates by insurance providers met customer expectations for transparency.

The expectation by customers has shifted. It is the responsibility of the insurance provider to ensure that claims process information is provided to the customer without the customer having to request the information.

Why Customers No Longer Tolerate Slow Insurance Processes

Insurance involves underwriting, verification, documentation, fraud checks, and human judgment. But complexity behind the scenes should not mean friction for customers.

Deloitte’s 2026 analysis of nearly 4,000 customer responses across 12 U.S. property and casualty insurers found that many customers still experience claims as complex, fragmented, and unclear.

  • Slow Processes Create Frustration
    Customers become frustrated when claims take too long or provide little information about what is happening.
  • Silence Feels Like Poor Service
    A simple “claim under review” message does not answer the customer’s real questions. Clear status updates reduce uncertainty.
  • Repeated Information Adds Friction
    Customers should not have to repeatedly submit the same documents or explain the same issue across different channels.
  • Automation Can Speed Up Routine Work
    AI and automation can help with claim intake, document processing, routing, status updates, and other repetitive tasks.
  • Humans Still Matter
    Complex or emotional claims require empathy, judgment, and human support. The goal is AI-assisted service, not human-free insurance.

The Business Takeaway

Faster insurance isn’t only about processing claims quickly—it’s about keeping customers informed, reducing unnecessary steps, and making every interaction feel effortless.

Personalization: From Generic Policies to Customer-Centric Experiences

Amazon personalizes based on what you might expect from other services: memorizing preferences, suggesting related options, and altering content based on your previous interactions. Amazon claims its personalization consists of altering how it presents content, based on things like product ratings and questions, as well as what you’ve purchased and what you’ve searched for.

Insurance can do similar things in similar ways.

Rather than using generic messages, insurers can create personalized messages for:

  • Explanations of coverage and benefits
  • Prevention of risks and loss
  • Reminders and renewals
  • Updates on claims
  • Recommendations and cross- selling of other coverage options

Based on the insured’s situation and risk, prevention and loss information can be presented in various ways. Personalization does not mean there must be a focus on selling. Personalization means there can be easier and more relevant communication.

According to McKinsey, AI can assist in accomplishing hyper personalization and a range of other tasks in insurance, including customer service, underwriting, and claims management.


The Trust and Transparency Expectations of Modern Policyholders

Policyholders need to be able to find information about their policies. They want to see their coverage and exclusions. They want to be able to easily find out the status of a claim and what, if any, additional information they need to turn over to the insurance company.

 Insurance companies can provide policyholders with digital dashboards, or similar resources, to provide policyholders with a centralized location to view information about their policy, claim, and the status of that claim.

Insurers strengthen relationships by making every interaction a positive, trust-building experience. Trust matters most at claim time: in the J.D. Power 2025 U.S. Auto Claims Satisfaction Study, trust ranked as the number one driver of claims satisfaction, ahead of settlement fairness and speed.

How AI and Data Are Powering Faster Insurance Experiences

AI and data are helping insurers reduce manual work, speed up decisions, and deliver more personalized customer experiences.

  • Smarter Document Processing
    AI can extract and organize information from forms, invoices, medical records, and other documents faster.
  • Faster Claims Processing
    AI can analyze claim details and route simple or complex cases to the right workflow.
  • Fraud Detection
    Machine learning can identify unusual patterns and flag potentially suspicious claims for further review.
  • 24/7 Customer Support
    AI-powered assistants can answer common questions, provide policy information, and share claim updates anytime.
  • Personalized Experiences
    Customer data can help insurers provide relevant coverage suggestions, reminders, and communication.
  • Better Employee Support
    AI can summarize customer histories and provide useful insights, helping agents make faster, informed decisions.
  • AI + Human Expertise
    The goal is not to replace people. AI handles repetitive tasks while employees focus on complex decisions, empathy, and customer needs.

What Insurance Companies Can Learn from Amazon’s Customer Obsession

Amazon has transformed shopping. Insurance shopping, servicing, and adjusting can also be transformed with improved accessibility and convenience.

Frictionless experiences are now expected. Insurance companies should incorporate more AI and automation in combination with personal touch-point support to give customers the individualized experience they expect while minimizing the effort and time it takes to support and service customers.

McKinsey has observed and studied the increasing preference and expectation of individualized insurance recommendations and support via a myriad of integrated support and service channels.

Insurance companies should implement these recommendations to provide effortless insurance solutions to the public and increase their client retention. Trust can also be earned and maintained by constantly providing useful and relevant information to the public about insurance services and products.

The Competitive Advantage of Delivering Frictionless Insurance Services

A frictionless experience for customers is a goal for every company. Creating such an experience has tremendous benefits for company operations, customer loyalty and company growth.

  1. Eliminate Customer Irritations
    Customers are irate over the need to complete such an onerous process to purchase insurance, make a claim or adjust their policy. Simplifying these would improve the customer experience.
  2. Keep Customers Loyal
    Nearly half of all customers who had poor digital claim experiences were not loyal and a full 52% of customers who had “just ok” claims experiences were not loyal. In contrast, 100% of customers who rated their claim experience as being “excellent” or “perfect” were loyal.
  3. Benefit Your Employees
    Insurers can implement software to facilitate digital claims to ensure employees are available to assist customers with more complex claims.
  4. Utilize Artificial Intelligence
    Insurers can simplify claims by integrating customer data, AI, and automation into end-to-end processes that keep customers notified of claim status. One carrier now uses AI to draft roughly 50,000 claims communications a day and finds them clearer and more empathetic than human-written versions (McKinsey, 2025).
  5. Positive Claims Outcomes
    Insurers utilizing the techniques outlined above improved their customers experience, employed their staff more effectively and eliminated customer frustration by better integrating the disparate systems and processes.

Conclusion: The Future of Insurance Is Built Around Customer Experience

Insurance customers expect digital experiences with their insurers that are on par with other digital experiences they have in their day-to-day lives.

Insurance companies need to adopt best-in-class digital processes to win and retain customers. To retain customers, companies must utilize a range of digital innovations including reducing process and experience friction, enhancing transparency and personally tailoring customer experiences. Utilizing artifiical intelligence (AI) and other digital innovations enables insurers to automate and enhance customer experiences while enabling employees to focus on more complex and demanding customer requirements.

Insurance is inherently complicated and digitizing the processes and integrating IT systems to provide customers with a simple and intuitive experience is critical to successfully differentiating a company’s insurance offering and increasing customer retention.

FAQs

Why do customers expect insurance to work like Amazon?

What do customers expect from digital insurance services?

How can insurers improve customer experience?

How does AI improve insurance customer experience?

What is the future of insurance customer experience?

Related Posts